How To Claim Extracurricular Expenses As Part Of Child Support
Extracurricular activities are a great way to keep children engaged and provide an avenue for them to explore and discover their passions while having fun, even though their costs can vary widely.
Every parent have flowing responsibilities to support their children in every way irrespective of the status of their marital relationship. So as a parent, you have the opportunity to support your child to make the best choice of extracurricular activities based on their strengths and passion.
In the event of a marital breakdown, it can be a big challenge for you as a parent if your child chooses extracurricular activities with a high price tag, especially when the total cost is in excess of the amounts estimated in the child support obligation.
Not forgetting that the general well-being of the children must continue to be treated on a balanced scale and if necessary, with legal sanction after marital separation, the law requires the separating parents to make financial arrangement to cover every reasonable and genuine expenses for the children of the marriage.
Money spent on a child’s extracurricular activities is clearly a reasonable and genuine expense made towards the well-being of the child.
So as a custodial parent, you can seek to have the child support obligation modified to include your child’s extracurricular expenses as extraordinary expenses.
The challenge is that it is difficult sometimes to determine if an expense like the cost of extracurricular activities could be classified as extraordinary expense for child support purposes. An experienced family lawyer can file a motion to modify the child support obligation with a court.
The Court’s usual approach to solving this challenge is by considering the following factors to determine what expenses can be categorized as special and extraordinary expenses:
- need
- reasonableness
- types of extraordinary expenses incurred by the parents before the separation
Before discussing how to claim your child/children’s extracurricular activities under extraordinary expenses, here’s Canada’s official/legal definition of Extraordinary Expenses.
What is “Extraordinary Expenses”?
(1.1) For the purposes of paragraphs (1)(d) and (f) below, the term extraordinary expenses means:
(a) expenses that exceed those that the spouse requesting an amount for the extraordinary expenses can reasonably cover, taking into account that spouse’s income and the amount that the spouse would receive under the applicable table or, where the Court has determined that the table amount is inappropriate, the amount that the Court has otherwise determined is appropriate; or
(b) where paragraph (a) is not applicable, expenses that the Court considers are extraordinary taking into account
(i) the amount of the expense in relation to the income of the spouse requesting the amount, including the amount that the spouse would receive under the applicable table or, where the Court has determined that the table amount is inappropriate, the amount that the Court has otherwise determined is appropriate,
(ii) the nature and number of the educational programs and extracurricular activities,
(iii) any special needs and talents of the child or children,
(iv) the overall cost of the programs and activities, and
(v) any other similar factor that the Court considers relevant.
Determining Special or Extraordinary Expenses
Under section 7 of the Federal Child Support Guidelines, the Court has a wide range of discretion to declare certain expenses as special and extraordinary expenses by considering the children’s best interest.
Extraordinary expenses can be school expenses such as paid tuition amount and other fees required for enrollment or attendance at an eligible institution. A precondition for enrollment may also be regarded as claimable school or educational expenses. For example, if a computer is a precondition for enrollment or admission, such will be considered as claimable educational expense.
Sometimes extracurricular activities do not form part of the core school syllabus, and are optional, yet still educational and informing. Such activities can include debating clubs, musicals activities, arts and sports.
Special or extraordinary expenses are determined according to Section 7 of the Federal Child Support Guidelines, which is as follows:
7 (1) In a child support order, the Court may on either spouse’s request provide for an amount to cover all or any portion of the following expenses (which may be estimated), taking into account the necessity of the expense in relation to the child’s best interests and the reasonableness of the expense in relation to the means of the spouses and those of the child and the family’s spending pattern prior to the separation:
(a) child care expenses incurred as a result of the custodial parent’s employment, illness, disability or education or training for employment
(b) the portion of the medical and dental insurance premiums attributable to the child
(c) health-related expenses that exceed insurance reimbursement by at least $100 annually, including orthodontic treatment, professional counseling provided by a psychologist, social worker, psychiatrist or any other person, physiotherapy, occupational therapy, speech therapy and prescription drugs, hearing aids, glasses and contact lenses
(d) extraordinary expenses for primary or secondary school education or for any other educational programs that meet the child’s particular needs
(e) expenses for post-secondary education
(f) extraordinary expenses for extracurricular activities
Sharing of Expense
(2) The guiding principle in determining an expense amount (referred to in subsection (1) above) is that the spouses share the expense in proportion to their respective incomes after deducting from the expense any contribution from the child.
Subsidies, Tax Deductions, etc.
(3) Subject to subsection (4), in determining the amount of an expense referred to in subsection (1), the Court must take into account any subsidies, benefits or income tax deductions or credits relating to the expense, and any eligibility to claim a subsidy, benefit or income tax deduction or credit relating to the expense.
Universal Child Care Benefit
(4) In determining the amount of an expense referred to in subsection (1), the Court shall not take into account any universal child care benefit or any eligibility to claim that benefit.
Note that Alberta Child Support Guidelines apply if you start your claim under the Family Law Act of Alberta.
A parent or a legal guardian of a child can initiate Child Support and Expense Claim before a court of competent jurisdiction in Alberta under the Divorce Act of Canada or Family Law Act of Alberta. The child himself, or any person with the permission of the Court can also initiate the claim.
For legal advice and representation in family law matters, we recommend you consult an Alberta family lawyer. A family lawyer can bring or defend a special and extraordinary expense claim on your behalf, and make submissions to the Court. Contact us for more information on what a family lawyer can do for you.
Satish offers professional legal advice and experience drawn from a multicultural background. He has spent his years in practice supporting clients through their family law, business law, real estate law, immigration law and wills and estates matters. He is able to find innovative solutions for his clients thanks to his rich, diverse background, which allows him to examine clients’ legal problems from a variety of different perspectives.
Know Your Mobility Rights: Custody Parent Moving With A Child
Mobility rights is a fairly common and unpredictable area of Family Law. It is unpredictable because the court can decide either way based on just one consideration.
After separation, a parent may wish to relocate for a number of reasons including employment opportunities, new relationship or to be close to the extended family.
The courts cannot stop a parent from relocating. However, if the move would excessively limit access or custody right of the other parent, this parent can take the matter to court. The court may end up preventing the custody parent from leaving the jurisdiction with the child or children.
The Only Consideration For A Parent’s Custody Mobility Rights
The Divorce Act makes it clear that the “best interests of the child are the only consideration to be taken into account in making orders concerning children”. In such cases the important question is “what is in the best interests of the children in the given circumstances?”.
How To Know What’s In The Best Interest Of A Child
The court must consider the following factors to make a decision whether a parent should be allowed to relocate with a child:
1. The importance of the child remaining with the custodial parent
2. Keeping contact with access parent
3. The views of the child
4. The degree of disruption to the child’s life as a result of removal from current family, schools and the community
2 Exemplary Cases Of Custodial Mobility Rights In Canada
1. Case of Gordon v. Goertz, [1996]
This has become the binding authority on related cases. Here, the mother wanted to relocate to Australia to study Orthodontics. The father opposed the move stating it would limit his access to the child.
The court first had to determine the “material change in circumstances affecting the child”. Upon establishing the material change in circumstances, the next stage is determining if it is in the “best interests of the child”.
In this case, the court allowed the mother to leave Canada with the child, while the father got order for visitations in Canada and Australia.
2. Case of Mam v. Wem, [2019]
In a recent case Mam v Wem, [2019], the Court had to determine whether it was in the best interest of the 15 year old daughter to temporarily relocate to China with her mother. The two older children of the marriage were also dependent and moving to China with their mother.
The position of the mother was that she had previously taught in Korea and she was familiar with the living conditions in china. She claimed that educational needs of her children can be satisfied by earning a decent living in China. Further, she believed the children will greatly benefit from new cultural experience.
In the end, the court denied the mother’s application for a temporary relocation after determining that it was not in the best interests of the children.
Since each case has it’s own unique peculiarities and circumstances, the outcome of your mobility rights case could go either way in the event that the other parent takes the issue to court.
It is important to get competent family legal advice to ensure that the best interests of all parties are protected if you are planning to custody parent planning to move with your child or children.
Satish offers professional legal advice and experience drawn from a multicultural background. He has spent his years in practice supporting clients through their family law, business law, real estate law, immigration law and wills and estates matters. He is able to find innovative solutions for his clients thanks to his rich, diverse background, which allows him to examine clients’ legal problems from a variety of different perspectives.
Alternative Dispute Resolution: How To Make Divorce Less Costly
Nobody goes into a marriage planning on one day getting divorced. Unfortunately, many marriages ultimately end with both spouses deciding to go their separate ways. While divorce is often portrayed in the media as a bitter and harsh process, there are ways to end a marriage without resorting to fighting, arguments and blame. Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) is one way to handle divorce to minimize stress on the divorcing spouses and ultimately make it less costly.
Alternative Dispute Resolution Techniques (or ADR process) have grown considerably in popularity in recent years as a way to avoid contentious litigation while ensuring that those going through a divorce still have their rights and best interests protected.
What is Alternative Dispute Resolution?
Alternative Dispute Resolution is essentially any dispute negotiation process whose primary aim is to keep the dispute out of court. This simply means that when divorcing spouses agree to an ADR process, they and their lawyers agree to keep the process out of court, and instead use mediation or arbitration process to settle their case.
Alternative Dispute Resolution Takes Team Work
What makes ADR process unique is that it involves teamwork. The divorcing parties work with a team of specialists that often include child behavior specialists, accountants, therapists, financial analysts and so on. Each spouse will have their own lawyer on hand to ensure that their best interests are still being advocated for. Each spouse and his or her attorney meets directly with the other spouse and his or her attorney to negotiate a settlement. The Parties arbitrate (negotiate) the issues in dispute.
There are benefits to the ADR process which make it a popular option for many divorcing parties these days. However, there is one scenarios where litigation is a better route to get the best outcome in a divorce case. We’ll discuss this scenario later in this article. First, let’s see the benefits of Alternative Dispute resolution.
3 Benefits of Alternative Dispute Resolution
Benefit #1: Alternative Dispute Resolution Tends To Be Cheaper Than Litigation
One great benefit of choosing to divorce through Alternative Dispute Resolution is that it tends to be much cheaper than litigation. Even with a team of specialists involved, the cost is often still less than going to court.
Benefit #2: Alternative Dispute Resolution Addresses Important Details
Another benefit of Alternative Dispute Resolution is that the final divorce settlement is less likely to overlook important details because each party’s interest is covered by professional input from a team of specialists. This means the divorcing parties are likely going to make the best decision during the ADR process before arriving at the final settlement.
Benefit #3: Alternative Dispute Resolution Takes Less Time
The thirst benefit is that Alternative Dispute Resolution also tends to be more time-efficient and less stressful for both parties. The ADR process eliminates the need to go through the whole drawn out process of going to court, attending multiple court sessions, and waiting for the decision of the court.
A Scenario where Litigation is Better than ADR
An important point to bear in mind about Alternative Dispute Resolution is that Trust and respect between both parties is fundamental to ensuring the ADR process works.
the ADR process is unlikely to succeed if the relationship between the spouses is hostile, especially if one spouse fears (or distrusts) the other spouse for any reason; like when one suspects the other will not be truthful about his or her financial situation. In such instance, the power of the court can help level the playing field for the parties involved.
Conclusion
The end of a marriage is a difficult time for both spouses, but that does not mean divorce negotiations necessarily have to make the process even more hostile and stressful.
If you are going through a divorce, it is important you talk to an experienced family lawyer for assistance. We will help you navigate the divorce process so you will understand what your divorce options are and how to protect your best interests while moving forward.
Satish offers professional legal advice and experience drawn from a multicultural background. He has spent his years in practice supporting clients through their family law, business law, real estate law, immigration law and wills and estates matters. He is able to find innovative solutions for his clients thanks to his rich, diverse background, which allows him to examine clients’ legal problems from a variety of different perspectives.